‘On the Pasta? That’s Horrible’: Boston Dad’s Olive Garden Request Leaves Waiter Stunned
BOSTON — A Boston family’s dinner out in Italy took an unexpected turn after the father asked a local waiter for Olive Garden’s Chicken Parmigiana—a request that drew a stunned and horrified response.
Viral TikTok Captures Awkward Exchange
The interaction was filmed by Gabby Donahue (@gabbydonahuee) on TikTok during her parents’ 30th wedding anniversary trip.
When her dad proudly showed the waiter a photo of Olive Garden’s dish, the server looked distressed and replied: “It doesn’t exist in Italy.”
The waiter then studied the photo and asked, “On the pasta?” before bluntly declaring: “No, that’s horrible”.
Americanized Italian Food
The incident highlights the cultural divide between Italian cuisine and its Americanized versions.
Chicken Parmesan, a U.S. favorite, evolved from melanzane alla parmigiana, a Southern Italian eggplant dish. Once in America, chicken became a popular substitute thanks to its availability and heartiness.
Internet Reactions
@gabbydonahuee @Olive Garden ‘s biggest fan 😭😭😭😭 #italy #cultureshock #chickenparm #olivegarden
The clip has drawn over 1 million views, with commenters noting the waiter looked “horrified,” “stressed,” and “offended.”
Some joked that trying to order Olive Garden abroad is a classic “American dad move.” Others shared similar stories of asking for U.S.-style Italian dishes overseas, only to be met with confusion.
A Lighthearted Ending
Though clearly shocked, the waiter eventually conceded with a polite, “That looks good.” Gabby’s dad promised to send some Olive Garden to Italy, turning the awkward moment into a story both families will likely remember for years.
In the end, he ordered pasta with ham and Alfredo sauce — enjoyable, but not the chicken parm he craved.
Would you ever ask for an American chain dish while dining abroad, or do you stick to local specialties? Share your take in the comments at SaludaStandard-Sentinel.com.
